Opinion
Let's Do AI Right
David L. Heiserman
AI is extremely fertile ground
for science & technology reporting. It takes a bit of study, but not
a whole lot of digging to find the limitations of most science
writers and bloggers. I will be writing more on this
particular topic, but I really want to make one thing clear:
Do not use the human brain as a model for
AI theory and design. There's a good reason: We
haven't the foggiest idea how the human brain works. That being the
case, you don't need
a PhD in epistemology or critical thinking to see the absolute folly
that is inherent in
comparing computers with the human brain and the human brain with
computers. We know how computers work, but we don't know how the
brain works. The comparison is logically invalid and thus leads us away
from fresh insight and a higher order of technological achievement. In
the 1970s, for example, I wrote a couple of books that proposed a model
for autonomous intelligence--machines that programmed themselves
according to the kind of external environment they encountered.
Comparison to the human brain was totally avoided. Instead, my projects
demonstrated a form of machine intelligence that had no dependence upon
our own fragmented understanding of human intelligence. Do you
understand the significance of that simple idea? Using today's
technology for modeling the behavior of a totally autonomous
intelligence gives us insight into a totally alien intelligence; and
there is a good chance that knowledge can applied to a higher order of
understanding of our own brains. Here are three of my books on this
topic and from that era. Although the technology is obsolete, the
principles offered in these books remain valid today. You can get your
own copies through Amazon for a dollar or less.
I have more recently published a Kindle book that summarizes the
content of all the my machine intelligence and do-it-yourself robot
projects:
|